About Us
Bell Insurance, Inc., an Alera Group Company, is a full-service independent insurance agency, offering a wide array of personal and commercial insurance products. Established in 1987, we serve the insurance needs of more than 9,000 individuals & families and 2,500 businesses.
In 2021, Bell joined Alera Group, an independent, national insurance and financial services firm created through the merger of like-minded, high-performing, entrepreneurial companies across the United States. Alera Group provides us access to resources, technical expertise, and best practices of a larger national firm while maintaining local personal care and thoughtful customer service. We position ourselves as leaders in the insurance world to ensure a high level of confidence in our expertise.
By choosing Bell, you aren’t just a number. You are a valued customer, and we are always here to offer guidance, answer your questions and identify ways to save you money. Our expert team assists customers through the entire insurance process, making it a hassle-free experience for you.
Get a quote: Submit this form.
Office hours and locations:
Monday-Friday, 8:30 a.m.-5 p.m. ET
Note: Our office observes temporary summer hours. During the summer months, our office closes at 1 p.m. ET on Fridays through the end of August.
- CHAMBERSBURG: (Phone) 717-264-7518 / (Fax) 717-264-1287
- GREENCASTLE: (Phone) 717-597-1151 / (Fax) 717-597-3141
- HANOVER: (Phone) 717-632-4500 / (Fax) 717-632-8203
- MECHANICSBURG: (Phone) 717-234-6530 / (Fax) 717-234-4163
Meet Our Team
Natalie Kinsinger
Marketing Manager
Natalie joined the team in 2013 and serves as our Marketing Manager. Her favorite part of her job is collaborating with staff, designing materials and managing marketing campaigns.
Prior to joining Alera, she worked in the communications department for the Pennsylvania Dental Association. Natalie earned her bachelor’s degree from Shippensburg University in Communications/Journalism with minors in English and Speech Communication. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her family and taking road trips.
Rose Mason
Personal Lines Account Manager
Rose is a 28-year seasoned Personal Lines Account Manager who specializes in personal insurance products such as auto, home, renters, umbrellas, and other individual-focused coverages. With nearly three decades of experience in the field, she excels at policy sales, service, underwriting and risk assessment. Rose serves as a trusted advisor to clients, often with long standing relationships. Her favorite part of her job is the relationships between her co-workers, companies and her clients. Always remembering the Golden Rule, “Do unto others as you would have others do unto you.”
Rose has been married to her best friend Dave for more than 20 years. They have a large, blended family with five adult children and 13 grandchildren. They also have a dog named Sammy. In their free time, they enjoy spending time with their grandchildren and taking excursions in their Jeep.
Angie Shaffer, CISR
Commercial Lines Account Manager
Angela is a Commercial Lines Account Manager and has been a valued team member since 2001. With more than 25 years of experience in the insurance industry, she specializes in quoting and servicing commercial accounts. Her favorite part of the job is helping clients save money while ensuring their assets are well protected.
Outside of work, Angela enjoys spending quality time with her husband, daughter, son-in-law and granddaughter. A true animal lover, she also cherishes get-togethers with friends and family.
Karen Shealer
Personal Lines Account Manager
As a Personal Lines Account Manager, Karen writes new business and ensures her customers are with the best company for their needs.
She has been a team member since 2000. Her favorite parts of her job are saving customers money by rewriting their insurance and helping new customers get insurance.
In her free time, Karen enjoys doing outside work and spending time at the beach.
Resources
General Resources
Get a quote: Submit this form.
How to File a Claim During Office Hours
Bell Insurance's normal office hours are 8 a.m. - 5 p.m. Monday through Friday. If you have sustained a loss and need to report a claim during those hours, please call us at (717) 264-7518.
How to File a Claim After Office Hours
In the event of an after-hours claim or emergency, please contact your carrier directly.
Solutions
Personal Insurance
- Auto Insurance, Life Insurance, Disability Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Long-Term Care Insurance, Medicare
Business Insurance
- Building and Business Property Insurance, Employment Practices Liability Insurance, General & Professional Liability, Commercial Auto Fleet & Surety, Business Overhead Expense Insurance, Worker's Compensation, Cyber Liability Insurance, Agribusiness
Employee Benefits
- Health Insurance, Vision Insurance, Dental Insurance, Voluntary Benefits
PDA (Pennsylvania Dental Association) Members:
Enjoy the convenience of one-stop shopping and the peace of mind that comes from having a single source for all your insurance needs. We are the endorsed insurance agency of the Pennsylvania Dental Association, providing a variety of business and personal insurance programs to Pennsylvania dentists, their families and staff. We offer an unparalleled understanding of your profession and coverage designed with your practice in mind.
We have access to the resources, technical expertise and best practices of a large national firm, while maintaining our personalized, local relationships. The innovative culture of Alera Group allows us to collaborate with national partners to expertly meet your unique needs.
Contact us for a free, no-obligation quote and start saving today!
We are pleased to offer the following products to PDA members: Professional Liability, Building and Business Property, Workers' Compensation, Cyber Suite Liability, Employment Practices Liability and Group Disability.
New Dentist Program
$50. That’s all new graduates pay for their first year of professional liability insurance. Learn more.
Contact Megan Geider or Gabrielle Wilday today for personalized customer service and a free, no-obligation quote.
EXPERT EDUCATION
Events and Webinars
Employee Benefits
Point Solutions, Proven: Why Vendor Sprawl Fails — and How to Identify What Actually Drives Impact
A clearer framework for sorting through point solutions to determine where investment may—or may not—deliver value.
September 15, 2026 at 01:00 pm CT | Virtual
Register Here
Employee Benefits
Primary Care as a Strategy: How Direct Primary Care Can Lower Costs and Improve Outcomes
A clearer understanding of how Direct Primary Care can be used as a strategic lever to improve outcomes while controlling total cost of care.
October 20, 2026 at 01:00 pm CT | Virtual
Register Here
Employee Benefits
AI Advantage in Benefits: Practical Use Cases That Support HR and Employees
A practical view of how AI can support benefits teams while improving the employee experience.
November 17, 2026 at 01:00 pm CT | Virtual
Register Here
THOUGHT LEADERSHIP
Insights
Employee Benefits
Legal Alert: IRS Issues ACA Affordability Percentage Adjustment for 2027
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has released Rev. Proc. 2026-26.
July 24, 2026
Find out more
Property and Casualty
Commercial Real Estate Insurance Market Shows Signs of Relief, With Conditions
There are emerging signs that the commercial property insurance market is beginning to soften. However, the benefits of this shift are not being felt uniformly across all real estate portfolios.
July 16, 2026
Find out more
Employee Benefits
Legal Alert: Clients With Massachusetts Private PFML Plans Renewing After July 1, 2026
Alert for any employer with at least one employee in Massachusetts, even if the employee is remote.
June 30, 2026
Find out more Employee Benefits
Legal Alert: PCORI Fees Due By July 31, 2026
This alert is of interest to all employers that sponsor self-insured group health plans, including Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs). Note that the PCORI fee does not apply to most health FSAs.
June 29, 2026
Find out more